When it comes to picking a new roof, two popular choices are metal and asphalt. Selecting the perfect roof for your home is a big decision, and understanding the differences between these options can make the choice easier. If you’re contemplating which one is right for your home, you’ve come to the right place.
This article will break down important considerations and guide you through the differences. Whether it’s cost, longevity, or aesthetic appeal, we’ve got you covered with expert insights to help you find the perfect match for your home.
What Is a Metal Roof?
A metal roof is a sturdy and long-lasting choice for homes and businesses, crafted from materials like steel or aluminum. Known for its resilience, it can handle extreme weather conditions, making it a smart option for areas with harsh climates.
Besides its durability, metal roofing makes homes more energy efficient by reflecting sunlight, which may potentially lower energy costs. While the initial cost might be higher, its longevity and minimal maintenance needs can make it a worthwhile investment.
Types of Metal Roofs
- Standing Seam Metal Roofs. These feature distinct raised seams for a sleek look and superior durability. They’re perfect for areas that experience extreme weather due to their strong structure. Plus, their modern appearance suits both homes and industrial buildings.
- Metal Shingles. Metal shingles have the look of traditional shingles but with added longevity. They come in various styles to enhance your Portland home’s aesthetic appeal. It’s a great choice if you’re looking for a versatile roofing option.
- Corrugated Metal Panels. These panels are durable and cost-effective. They’re often used in rustic or industrial settings and can provide excellent protection. If you’re on a tight budget, this is a practical option without sacrificing quality.
- Metal Slate Roofing. Metal slate mimics the elegance of slate tiles but offers the same sophistication with less weight and more durability. It’s a stunning choice that withstands weathering beautifully, perfect for those wanting a refined look with the strength of metal.
- Metal Tile Roofing. These tiles replicate the look of ceramic or clay tiles and offer a classic aesthetic. However, they deliver enhanced durability and require less maintenance, and are ideal for Portland homeowners seeking a traditional look.
Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs
| Pros | Cons |
| Longevity. Metal roofs can last 40 to 70 years, which is much longer than many other roofing options. This means fewer replacements and less hassle over the years. Durability. These roofs stand up well against harsh weather, including high winds and heavy rain. They’re resistant to fire and pests and offer reliable protection for your home. Energy Efficiency. Metal roofs help lower your cooling bills by reflecting sunlight and reducing heat buildup. This makes them ideal for those wanting to save on energy costs. It’s a win-win for your wallet and the environment. Low Maintenance. With minimal upkeep required, metal roofs reduce the time and money spent on repairs. They resist mold and corrosion, which keeps them looking great for years. | Initial Cost. Metal roofs can be pricey upfront. This can deter people looking for immediate savings. However, the long-term benefits often balance the initial expense. Noise. Without proper insulation, rain and hail can make metal roofs noisy, which can be bothersome during storms. Soundproofing materials can help, but they add to the cost. Expansion and Contraction. Temperature changes can cause metal roofs to expand and contract, and potentially cause issues. This can affect fasteners over time if not installed correctly. Regular checks can help mitigate problems. Complex Installation. Metal roofs require specialized skills for proper installation. This means higher labor costs compared to other roofing materials. It’s important to hire experienced roofing contractors to get the job done right. |
What Is an Asphalt Roof?
An asphalt roof is a popular choice due to its affordability and versatility. Made from layers of asphalt shingles, it offers a classic look that fits well with various home styles. Although it may not last as long as metal, it’s easy to install and maintain. Asphalt is practical for those seeking a straightforward and economical roofing solution.
Types of Asphalt Roofs
- Three-Tab Shingles. These offer a uniform, straightforward appearance and are budget-friendly. They’re popular among homeowners looking for a classic look on a budget.
- Architectural Shingles. Offering more depth and texture, architectural asphalt shingle roofs enhance curb appeal. They’re thicker and more durable, and are an excellent choice for added strength and visual appeal.
- Premium Shingles. These mimic high-end materials like slate tiles and add luxury to any home. They provide excellent aesthetics and performance, ideal for those who want to elevate their style.
- Performance Shingles. Engineered for superior weather resistance, these shingles are perfect for harsh climates. They offer enhanced durability and protection, making them a reliable choice for long-lasting performance.
Pros and Cons of Asphalt Roofs
| Pros | Cons |
| Affordability. Traditional asphalt shingles cost less than metal roofs and are often accessible for many budgets. This is a popular choice for homeowners looking to manage expenses. Ease of Installation. The installation process is straightforward and quick, which may reduce labor costs. For urgent roofing needs, asphalt can be a convenient choice. Variety of Styles. Asphalt is available in numerous colors and styles that can easily match different architectural designs. This flexibility will help you find a look that suits your Portland home’s aesthetic. | Shorter Lifespan. Asphalt roofs generally last between 15 and 30 years, which means more frequent roof replacements compared to metal. This can add up over time and may increase overall maintenance efforts. Weather Vulnerability. Asphalt is more prone to damage from severe weather like heavy winds and hail. This can affect the roof’s lifespan and lead to unexpected repair costs. Environmental Impact. Made from petroleum-based materials, asphalt shingles aren’t the most eco-friendly option. They often end up in landfills, which contributes to environmental waste. Heat Absorption. Asphalt tends to absorb heat, leading to higher cooling costs, especially in hot climates. This energy inefficiency might not be ideal for everyone, as it can affect comfort levels inside the home. |
Asphalt vs Metal Roof: How Do They Differ?
Installation
Metal roofing installation typically requires specialized skills and tools, which may lead to higher labor costs. It’s essential to find qualified and experienced professionals to handle the job expertly. In contrast, asphalt shingle installation can be completed quickly and is more straightforward, making it a budget-friendly option for many.
Durability
When it comes to standing up to the elements, metal roofs are top-notch and can resist wear from weather and time. They’re less likely to face damage from wind or hail compared to asphalt. While asphalt is durable, it may require more attention if you live in an area with severe weather.
Cost
Metal roofing generally costs more initially, but its long-lasting nature can offer savings in the long run. Asphalt is more affordable upfront, but frequent replacements could add up over time. It’s best to weigh initial expense against long-term investment to help you decide what fits your financial plan best.
Energy Efficiency
Metal roofs reflect solar heat effectively, which helps homes stay cooler and reduces energy costs. This feature makes metal a smart choice for those who are after energy efficiency. Asphalt absorbs heat, which can raise cooling expenses, especially during the hotter months.
Environmental Impact
Many metal roofs can be recycled at the end of their lifespan and are often made from recycled materials, making them environmentally friendly. Asphalt, on the other hand, often ends up in landfills. If sustainability is important to you, metal might be a better choice for reducing your carbon footprint.
Metal vs Asphalt Roof Cost
When comparing costs, metal roofing generally costs more initially than asphalt shingles. However, the longer lifespan and lower maintenance can make metal a worthwhile investment over time. Asphalt shingles are more affordable upfront and are ideal for those with a tight budget, but they might require more frequent replacement.
Typically, in Portland, metal roofing can range from $8 to $16 per square foot, and asphalt shingles might cost around $5 per square foot without the labor cost. Pricing for both depends on factors like the type of material and installation complexity. It’s important to check with local contractors for specific price estimates, as costs can vary widely based on location, materials, and installation.
Is Asphalt Stronger Than Metal?
When it comes to strength, metal generally outperforms asphalt. Metal roofs are built to withstand harsh conditions, including strong winds and heavy rainfall, making them highly resilient. Asphalt, while durable, may not offer the same level of protection in extreme weather. Additionally, metal’s resistance to fire and pests gives it an edge in terms of overall robustness. For those prioritizing strength and longevity, metal is often the preferred choice.
When Should You Not Use a Metal Roof?
A metal roof might not be suitable for homes in coastal areas since salt can cause rust over time. The noise from rain or hail can also be bothersome without proper insulation. Additionally, if your budget is tight, the higher upfront cost might be a concern.
If your home lacks structural support for a heavier roof, metal may not be ideal. Consider these factors and consult with roofing professionals to determine the best fit for your needs.
Metal Roof vs Asphalt Roof: What Should You Choose?
Choosing between metal and asphalt roofs depends on your specific needs and priorities. If you’re looking for durability and a long lifespan, metal might be the way to go, even with its higher initial investment. Metal roofs also offer energy savings by reflecting sunlight, which can reduce cooling costs.
On the other hand, if you’re on a tight budget and need a quick, cost-effective solution, asphalt shingles are a great option. They come in various styles and are easy to install, which may appeal to those who want a straightforward approach. Consider your budget, climate, and how long you are planning to stay in your home before deciding. Weighing these factors will help you choose what is best for your property.
Protect and Secure Your Home With Expert Roofing Solutions From Armadas Exterior LLC
A roof is a significant investment in your home’s future, and determining the right fit requires a careful analysis of your priorities and environment. By weighing metal’s longevity against asphalt’s affordability, you can confidently select what best fits your lifestyle and budget.
Here at Armadas Exterior LLC, we can guide you through this important decision. We specialize in providing professional roofing services for Portland homeowners. With years of experience as a family-owned business, you can count on our team to provide personalized service you can rely on.
Call us today for a no-obligation consultation, and let us help you protect your home with the ideal roofing solution!