Solar Roof Options: Comparing Panels vs. Solar Shingles for Your Home

As the world focuses more on renewable energy and the need to save money intensifies, homeowners are turning to their roofs to help generate electricity. Fortunately, there are various solar roof solutions, including solar panels and a newer option—solar roof shingles (also known as solar shingles or solar tiles).

Let’s explore the benefits, installation process, energy production, and overall efficiency of today’s most popular solar energy systems. This thorough solar installation comparison will help you decide which solar solution fits your needs, budget, and property.

Why Choose a Solar Roof?

A solar roof lets homeowners produce electricity directly from their house, harnessing the clean and renewable power of the sun. Across the country and the world, more buildings are being equipped with rooftop solar systems as the price of solar technology falls and local incentives make solar energy even more cost-effective.

Solar power can help you:

• Save money on utility bills by offsetting electricity from the grid
• Protect your property from rising energy costs
• Contribute to a more sustainable, cleaner world through renewable energy
• Increase your property’s resale value
• Achieve energy independence, especially when paired with energy storage

The National Renewable Energy Laboratory and the North American Board of Certified Energy Practitioners both emphasize the importance of high-quality solar installations and recommend working with certified energy practitioners to achieve the best results.

Panels vs. Shingles

Traditional Solar Panels

Solar panels (photovoltaic panels) are the most recognizable solar system solution for homes and commercial buildings. They contain solar cells that absorb sunlight and convert it into power. Panels are typically installed atop racks on your roof, but can also be ground-mounted if space allows.

Benefits:

• High Efficiency and Power Output. Most modern panels offer a power rating between 250 and 450 watts and reach efficiency levels up to 22% (NREL). This means they can generate more energy in a given amount of space.
• Mature Technology. Panels have been installed globally for decades, making them reliable and widely supported by solar companies and certified energy practitioners.
• Cost-Effective. The cost per watt is among the lowest of all the products available (~$2-$3 per watt after incentives). They qualify for tax credits and local incentives.
• Installation Process. Typically straightforward, often completed in 1–3 days.

Drawbacks:

• Aesthetics. Solar panels are visible and may not blend seamlessly with every home design, something to consider if you live in a historic district or under strict homeowners association (HOA) guidelines.
• Requires Roof Penetrations. Mounting racks may affect existing roofing.
• Additional Load. Panels and racks add weight to the roof structure.

Suitability

Traditional solar panels are best for existing roofs in good condition and for households wanting to maximize power output at the lowest cost. They also offer clear financial savings and an established installation process, with plenty of trained installers on the market.

Solar Shingles and Integrated Solar Tile Roofing

Solar shingles and solar tiles are an integrated solar roofing solution, offering both the protective function of traditional roofing materials and the ability to generate power. Each unit embeds solar cells into a shingle or tile, blending into the roof for a clean look.

Benefits:

• Seamless, Integrated Design. Solar shingle installation provides a low-profile roof that is indistinguishable from conventional New Roof materials. It’s an ideal choice for new builds or roof replacement projects.
• Dual Function. These systems both cover and protect the roof while producing clean energy.
• Appeals to HOAs and Historic Districts. Many solar roof shingles comply with strict appearance codes.
• Innovative Technology. Continually improving with each generation, some of the best brands now offer 20–30-year power warranties.

Drawbacks:

• Higher Cost. Installing solar shingles costs $3.50 to $6 or more per watt, which is higher than panels because it often requires labor-intensive roofing and electrical work.
• Lower Power Output. Solar tiles and shingles currently have lower efficiency (12–17%) compared to panels, so more roof area may be required to meet electricity needs.
• Specialized Installation. Fewer contractors are certified; research the solar companies and installers available in your area.
• Installation Process. More complex than panel installation, lasting 1–2 weeks, and best paired with a complete roof replacement.

Suitability

Solar shingle installation is best for new builds or when a roof replacement is already needed. It’s also suitable for homeowners who value curb appeal or must adhere to strict local building codes. While the upfront cost can be higher, the integrated design and aesthetics are a clear win for some.

Comparison Table: Solar Panels vs. Solar Roof Shingles

Feature	Traditional Solar Panels	Solar Shingles and Solar Tiles
Appearance	Visible, raised	Low-profile, integrated
Efficiency	16–22%	12–17%
Power Rating	250–450W per panel	35–80W per shingle/tile
Cost per Watt	$2–$3	$3.50–$6+
Installation Time	1–3 days	1–2 weeks
Roof Impact	Adds weight, minor intrusion	Replaces traditional roof, seamless
Best For	Existing roofs, budget-focused	New roofs, premium builds, visual appeal
Incentives	Tax credit, net metering	Tax credit, some local incentives
Warranties	25–30 years	20–30 years

Factors to Consider for Your Solar Energy System

Before deciding on which solar roof option to choose, it’s important to weigh several key factors that can influence the performance, cost, and suitability of your solar installation:

• Roof Condition. Is a replacement imminent? If so, consider integrated solar options.
• Budget and Incentives. Total up-front costs vs. long-term savings and available tax credits, rebates, and net metering.
• Sun Exposure. The more direct sunlight your roof receives, the more electricity produced, the better your payback.
• Aesthetics. The importance of seamless design vs. capacity is that panels are used for maximum energy production, and shingles are used for integrated appearance.
• Power Needs. Calculate how much electricity your household uses to size your solar system accordingly.
• HOA/Local Building Codes. Some jurisdictions only allow specific visual forms.
• Maintenance and Warranties. Choose products offering strong power output guarantees and work with certified energy practitioners.
• Installer Choice. Work with NABCEP-certified installers from leading solar companies; experience matters.

Ready for a Solar Upgrade? Contact Armadas Exterior LLC Today!

Choosing between traditional solar panels and solar roof shingles depends on your budget, roof condition, and aesthetic preferences. Solar panels offer higher efficiency and cost-effectiveness, while solar shingles provide an integrated, seamless look ideal for new roofs or replacements.

Choosing the right solar solution for your home can be a complex decision, but you don’t have to make it alone. At Armadas Exterior LLC, our expert team specializes in both traditional solar panel installations and cutting-edge solar shingle roofing. We’re committed to providing honest guidance, quality craftsmanship, and seamless project management, from your initial consultation to the final inspection.

Call us for your free solar consultation—take the next step toward lower energy bills and a cleaner, more sustainable future for your home!